isPaidTier read a future stripeCurrentPeriodEnd as proof of payment, and
Stripe stamps a current period on an incomplete subscription all the
same. A checkout whose first charge failed therefore carried a period
end a month out with nothing paid behind it, and every ceiling the
cardless trial puts on an unpaid account (200 GB of storage, unlimited
projects, unlimited workspaces) came off with it.
Written as a deny list of the two statuses that mean no charge has ever
gone through, so a real customer whose renewal failed keeps the full
plan for the period they already paid for.
hasBillingAccess reads the same column the same way and is deliberately
left alone: being wrong there locks a paying customer out, and the SQL
in buildBillingAccessWhereInput has to move with it.
The trial is granted in the credentials signup route and on the
verification link, and an account created by Google or GitHub goes
through neither: the Prisma adapter writes it directly. Since checkout
no longer offers a trial either, such an account reached a locked
product and an immediate bill, which is the opposite of what the signup
page promised it.
The address is already proven at this point, because the signIn callback
turns away an OAuth profile that reports its email as unverified, and
the grant is idempotent, so nothing here can hand out a second trial.
Three places still carried the old promise. The register form, which is where
the CTA lands and where the trial is granted, said nothing about it at all, so
the landing page's claim had to be taken on faith across a page load. The
comparison profile summary still described the trial without mentioning the
card. And the CtaLink comment quoted a button label that no longer exists.
The hero and closing CTAs now read 'Open dashboard' for a signed-in visitor.
That button already pointed at /dashboard for them, and offering a free trial
to someone who is mid-subscription reads as a bug. The pricing card keeps the
short label because it sits directly under 'No credit card' and the card
narrows to about 230px at the md breakpoint, where the long label would wrap
out of a fixed-height button.
The registration spec asserted that a brand new account lands on /settings,
which was true only because registering left trialEndsAt empty. It is now
filled at signup, so the account has billing access and the dashboard lets it
through to the onboarding wizard. That redirect is the done condition of the
cardless trial, so the spec should hold it.
yusufipek